Jones and Stallybrass 2000 - Revision history

Wtrettien: /* Of ghosts and garments: the materiality of memory on the Renaissance stage */

2012-09-17T01:36:31Z

Of ghosts and garments: the materiality of memory on the Renaissance stage

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:36, 17 September 2012
Line 124:		Line 124:

	== Of ghosts and garments: the materiality of memory on the Renaissance stage ==		== Of ghosts and garments: the materiality of memory on the Renaissance stage ==

			:"The most prominent feature of Renaissance ghosts is precisely their gross materiality. They appear to us conspicuously clothed. Not only are they clothed, but after they leave the stage, their clothes, having a vulgar material value, are carefully stored away or resold." (248)

			:"The material clothes, indeed, have the ability to conjure up the dead and to materialize them upon the stage." (248)

			:"But why should these ghosts be so precisely clothed and situated? It is, mundanely, so that they will be known. If a ghost says, above all, 'remember me,' remembrance is materialized through the physical attributes that named the person when alive. And those attributes are above all ''superficial'': they lie on the surface, they can be displayed to the eye (Andrugio's ghost is "''displayed''"). If a ghost is a mnemonic, the Renaissance ghost is often remembered by what it wears, what is most visible and tactile -- its clothes." (249)

Wtrettien: /* (In)alienable possessions: Griselda, clothing, and the exchange of women */

2012-09-17T01:26:29Z

(In)alienable possessions: Griselda, clothing, and the exchange of women

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:26, 17 September 2012
Line 119:		Line 119:
	:"If the Renaissance stage demands that we 'see' particular body parts (the breast, the penis, the naked body), it also reveals that such fixations are inevitably unstable. The actor is both boy and woman, and he/she embodies the fact that sexual fixations are not the product of any categorical fixity of gender. Indeed, all attempts to fix gender are necessarily prosthetic: that is, they suggest the attempt to supply an imagined deficiency by the exchange of male clothes for female clothes or of female clothes for male clothes; by displacement from male to female space or from female to male space; by the replacement of male with female tasks or of female with male tasks. But all elaborations of the prosthesis which will supply the 'deficiency' can secure no essence. On the contrary, they suggest that gender itself is a fetish, the production of an identity through the fixation upon specific parts. The imagined truth of gender which a post-Renaissance culture would later construct is dependent upon the disavowal of the fetishism of gender, the disavowal of gender as fetish. In its place, post-Renaissance culture would put a fantasied biology of the 'real'." (217)		:"If the Renaissance stage demands that we 'see' particular body parts (the breast, the penis, the naked body), it also reveals that such fixations are inevitably unstable. The actor is both boy and woman, and he/she embodies the fact that sexual fixations are not the product of any categorical fixity of gender. Indeed, all attempts to fix gender are necessarily prosthetic: that is, they suggest the attempt to supply an imagined deficiency by the exchange of male clothes for female clothes or of female clothes for male clothes; by displacement from male to female space or from female to male space; by the replacement of male with female tasks or of female with male tasks. But all elaborations of the prosthesis which will supply the 'deficiency' can secure no essence. On the contrary, they suggest that gender itself is a fetish, the production of an identity through the fixation upon specific parts. The imagined truth of gender which a post-Renaissance culture would later construct is dependent upon the disavowal of the fetishism of gender, the disavowal of gender as fetish. In its place, post-Renaissance culture would put a fantasied biology of the 'real'." (217)

	== (In)alienable possessions: Griselda, clothing, and the exchange of women ==		== (In)alienable possessions: Griselda, clothing, and the exchange of women ==

			"rerobings" of the story of Griselda -- "translations" of clothing that enact power relations and shape social identities (221)

	== Of ghosts and garments: the materiality of memory on the Renaissance stage ==		== Of ghosts and garments: the materiality of memory on the Renaissance stage ==

Wtrettien: /* Transvestism and the 'body beneath': speculating on the boy actor */

2012-09-17T01:25:26Z

Transvestism and the 'body beneath': speculating on the boy actor

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:25, 17 September 2012
Line 111:		Line 111:
	:"In the Renaissance theater, 'character' is always haunted by clothes that give a name or that have conversed with other bodies. They stage the otherness that materializes the impossibility of self-possession. If we do not understand these clothes, we do not understand the action, or the actors, or the theater itself. But that theater, far from reproducing the orderly transmissions of a cloth economy, obsessively staged the misunderstanding of clothes, clothes as a site of crisis from which nostalgia for a lost time of splendid armor could offer no reprieve. The transmission of clothes figures the formulation and dissolution of identity, the ways in which the subject is possessed and dispossessed, touched and haunted by the materials it inhabits." (206)		:"In the Renaissance theater, 'character' is always haunted by clothes that give a name or that have conversed with other bodies. They stage the otherness that materializes the impossibility of self-possession. If we do not understand these clothes, we do not understand the action, or the actors, or the theater itself. But that theater, far from reproducing the orderly transmissions of a cloth economy, obsessively staged the misunderstanding of clothes, clothes as a site of crisis from which nostalgia for a lost time of splendid armor could offer no reprieve. The transmission of clothes figures the formulation and dissolution of identity, the ways in which the subject is possessed and dispossessed, touched and haunted by the materials it inhabits." (206)

	== Transvestism and the 'body beneath': speculating on the boy actor ==		== Transvestism and the 'body beneath': speculating on the boy actor ==

			:"We need to conceptualize the erotics of Renaissance drama in totally unfamiliar ways if we are to make sense of these queer stagings of the boy actor, stagings that insist that we see what, visually, we cannot see." (213)

			:"The Renaissance theater was thus the site for the prosthetic production of the sexualized body through the clothing of the body and the mimed gestures of love. But it was also he site where that prosthetic production was dramatically staged and speculated upon, as the boy actor undressed, as the fixations of spectators were drawn back and forth between the clothes which embodied and determined a particular sexual identity and contradictory fantasies of the body beneath -- the body of a woman, the body of a boy; a body with and without breasts." (216)

			:"If the Renaissance stage demands that we 'see' particular body parts (the breast, the penis, the naked body), it also reveals that such fixations are inevitably unstable. The actor is both boy and woman, and he/she embodies the fact that sexual fixations are not the product of any categorical fixity of gender. Indeed, all attempts to fix gender are necessarily prosthetic: that is, they suggest the attempt to supply an imagined deficiency by the exchange of male clothes for female clothes or of female clothes for male clothes; by displacement from male to female space or from female to male space; by the replacement of male with female tasks or of female with male tasks. But all elaborations of the prosthesis which will supply the 'deficiency' can secure no essence. On the contrary, they suggest that gender itself is a fetish, the production of an identity through the fixation upon specific parts. The imagined truth of gender which a post-Renaissance culture would later construct is dependent upon the disavowal of the fetishism of gender, the disavowal of gender as fetish. In its place, post-Renaissance culture would put a fantasied biology of the 'real'." (217)

	== (In)alienable possessions: Griselda, clothing, and the exchange of women ==		== (In)alienable possessions: Griselda, clothing, and the exchange of women ==

	== Of ghosts and garments: the materiality of memory on the Renaissance stage ==		== Of ghosts and garments: the materiality of memory on the Renaissance stage ==

Wtrettien: /* The circulation of clothes and the making of the English theater */

2012-09-17T01:00:28Z

The circulation of clothes and the making of the English theater

@@ Line 88: / Line 88: @@
 :"In worked texts they recorded their ingenuity, their reading, their collaboration and their loyalties to causes beyond their families and houses. They plied the needle to materialize their views of the world and to be remembered as makers of objects that commemorated themselves, their families and their country's triumphs." (170)
 == The circulation of clothes and the making of the English theater ==
 == Transvestism and the 'body beneath': speculating on the boy actor ==

Wtrettien: /* The needle and the pen: needlework and the appropriation of printed texts */

2012-09-17T00:49:13Z

The needle and the pen: needlework and the appropriation of printed texts

← Older revision		Revision as of 00:49, 17 September 2012
Line 59:		Line 59:

	needle VS. pen -- Vives recommends reading and writing over sewing (141)		needle VS. pen -- Vives recommends reading and writing over sewing (141)

			William Greenhill's sermon dedicated to Princess Elizabeth, Charles I's daughter, recommended she spend more time with her pen and books than with the needle (142)

			:"Silk was expensive, as were the tools of fine needlework. Accordingly, moralists writing for the middling sort linked decorative stitchery to vices contrary to the thrifty industry than needlework was made to signify in conduct books and sermons." (143-144)

			Thomas Powell, ''Art of Thriving, or the plaine pathway to preferment'' (1635), "associates expensive needlework with the reading of romances and reading with frivolous writing, all equally unsuited to bourgeois daughters" (144)

			:"Early modern women found themselves in a marketplace where conduct manuals defining feminine virtue as containment within the household circulated along with how-to books encouraging women to demonstrate their textile virtuosity in public. This new system of print culture was fed by more or less explicit advertisements for incompatible groups -- humanists and moralists at court, pattern salesmen blazoning their commodities, defenders of different religions, city poets satirizing contemporary fashions. the crazy-quilt of conservative gender theory and new technical practices opened up unpredictable possibilities for the design and display of textile work by women. The needle could ''be'' a pen." (144)

			Esther Inglis -- "She is the author, that is, the maker, of every element of her books." (148)

			:"Any clear distinction between public and private, inner and outer spaces, was undone in material ways by English needlewomen. Whatever repressive and isolating effects stitchery as a disciplinary apparatus might have been intended to produce, women used it to connect to one another within domestic settings and to connect with the outer world, as well." (148)

			:"Needlework on caps, coifs, and scarves as well as samples, cushions and wall hangings was hardly a private habit; rather, it encouraged buyers of pattern books to choose among publicly printed designs and combine them in their own way." (148-149)

			:"'''The needleworker combined a variety of forms from a variety of sources; her 'private' undergrament is actually a record of her take on visual vocabularies circulating in the public world of print.'''" (149)

			:"''Copia'', symmetry, and variety are the principles of composition, rather than narrative detail." (149)

			embroidery "freely adapts the narrative to a flat surface and fills its empty spaces with the flora and fauna that printed pattern books made available to embroiderers" (149)

			Helena and Hermia linked by the needlework they did together as children in ''Midsummer Night's Dream'' (153)

			embroidered caskets, generally "broke down the needle-pen opposition: decorated with silken needlework, they contained pens and ink." (59)

			:"Needlewomens' choice of figures such as Esther and the Queen of Sheba, and their use of internationally circulating prints as models for designs, typify the appropriation of public visual discourses through which they took part in the production of political and national histories." (162)

			:"In worked texts they recorded their ingenuity, their reading, their collaboration and their loyalties to causes beyond their families and houses. They plied the needle to materialize their views of the world and to be remembered as makers of objects that commemorated themselves, their families and their country's triumphs." (170)

	== The circulation of clothes and the making of the English theater ==		== The circulation of clothes and the making of the English theater ==

Wtrettien: /* The needle and the pen: needlework and the appropriation of printed texts */

2012-09-16T22:29:26Z

The needle and the pen: needlework and the appropriation of printed texts

← Older revision		Revision as of 22:29, 16 September 2012
Line 48:		Line 48:
	:"During the fifteenth and early sixteenth centuries, Englishwomen had provided spun yarn to an industry in expansion, but by 1600 textil virtue was more than ever a moral ideal rather than an economic reality. No traditional or new moral constants invoked to define the virtuous bourgeois daughter or wife guaranteed that the cloth trades would continue to sustain threadmakers as they spun." (116)		:"During the fifteenth and early sixteenth centuries, Englishwomen had provided spun yarn to an industry in expansion, but by 1600 textil virtue was more than ever a moral ideal rather than an economic reality. No traditional or new moral constants invoked to define the virtuous bourgeois daughter or wife guaranteed that the cloth trades would continue to sustain threadmakers as they spun." (116)

	== The needle and the pen: needlework and the appropriation of printed texts ==		== The needle and the pen: needlework and the appropriation of printed texts ==

			:"We argue that even as a woman bent over her sewing appeared to be fulfilling the requirement of obedient domesticity, she could be materializing a counter-memory for herself, registering her links to other women and to the larger world of culture and politics." (134)

			patterns from many different nations and places; "The London gentlewoman sitting at home at her needlework was in fact being constituted by the textile practices of far-flung nations and faiths." (137)

			Taylor's poem, compares gathering patterns to jumping about like a squirrel from tree to tree -- "the pleasures of flightiness" (139)

			Juan Vives, recommended copying out sententiae for women; "Although Vives does not mention samplers, this was a form of needlework that corresponded precisely to his desire to focus the mind on proper objects: working pious maxims in thread drew both kinds of activity together." (141)

			needle VS. pen -- Vives recommends reading and writing over sewing (141)

	== The circulation of clothes and the making of the English theater ==		== The circulation of clothes and the making of the English theater ==

Wtrettien: /* The fate of spinning: Penelope and the Three Fates */

2012-09-16T22:25:05Z

The fate of spinning: Penelope and the Three Fates

← Older revision		Revision as of 22:25, 16 September 2012
Line 38:		Line 38:

	spinning, very unprofitable in England		spinning, very unprofitable in England

			"conflict at the heart of representations of spinning"
			* "On the one hand, it was recognized as the absolute precondition for all textile production and as the required labor of poorer women. On the other, it was an ideological program for the production of virtuous femininity across class lines. Consequently, it was recommended for aristocratic and middle-class daughters as the necessary ''habitus'' that produced 'woman,' while the actual work of producing thread was trivialized or ignored." (110)

			weaving was "increasingly becoming a man's craft in early modern Europe. During the Middle Ages, women worked at weaving wool as well as silk, but by the middle sixteenth century they had been forced out of most of the clothworking guilds throughout Europe. At the same time, spinning was celebrated in the attempt to produce an ideal woman valued for her 'simplicity.'" (111)

			:"Beginning in the middle sixteenth century, under James, and after the Restoration, the English wool trade declined radically. The industrial recession of the seventeenth century, combined with politically motivated Continental embargoes on English wool and the use there of wool from Ireland and Spain, as well as locally driven but wrongheaded clothiers' demands that exports of raw wool should be stopped so that English workers alone could profit from finishing it, led to much lower prices for local wool, to much less wool-raising, and consequently to less opportunity for spinners." (115)

			:"During the fifteenth and early sixteenth centuries, Englishwomen had provided spun yarn to an industry in expansion, but by 1600 textil virtue was more than ever a moral ideal rather than an economic reality. No traditional or new moral constants invoked to define the virtuous bourgeois daughter or wife guaranteed that the cloth trades would continue to sustain threadmakers as they spun." (116)

	== The needle and the pen: needlework and the appropriation of printed texts ==		== The needle and the pen: needlework and the appropriation of printed texts ==

Wtrettien: /* The fate of spinning: Penelope and the Three Fates */

2012-09-14T01:33:27Z

The fate of spinning: Penelope and the Three Fates

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:33, 14 September 2012
Line 35:		Line 35:
	:"The power of Velazquez's painting is its power to rematerialize the processes through which the symbolic is manufactured." (103)		:"The power of Velazquez's painting is its power to rematerialize the processes through which the symbolic is manufactured." (103)

	== The fate of spinning: Penelope and the Three Fates ==		== The fate of spinning: Penelope and the Three Fates ==

			spinning, very unprofitable in England

	== The needle and the pen: needlework and the appropriation of printed texts ==		== The needle and the pen: needlework and the appropriation of printed texts ==

Wtrettien: /* Arachne's web: Velazquez's Las Hilanderas */

2012-09-13T20:03:27Z

Arachne's web: Velazquez's Las Hilanderas

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:03, 13 September 2012
Line 32:		Line 32:

	Arachne; Ovid is sympathetic to her, Sandys's translation makes her into a political/sexual agitator; Browne pastoralizes her		Arachne; Ovid is sympathetic to her, Sandys's translation makes her into a political/sexual agitator; Browne pastoralizes her

			:"The power of Velazquez's painting is its power to rematerialize the processes through which the symbolic is manufactured." (103)

	== The fate of spinning: Penelope and the Three Fates ==		== The fate of spinning: Penelope and the Three Fates ==

Wtrettien: /* Arachne's web: Vlazquez's Las Hilanderas */

2012-09-13T20:00:20Z

Arachne's web: Vlazquez's Las Hilanderas

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:00, 13 September 2012
Line 27:		Line 27:
	== Yellow starch: fabrications of the Jacobean court ==		== Yellow starch: fabrications of the Jacobean court ==

	== Arachne's web: ~~Vlazquez~~'s Las Hilanderas ==		== Arachne's web: Velazquez's Las Hilanderas ==

			Velazquez, ''Las Hilanderas'' (The Spinners); spinners in foreground, tapestry lit in background; has led modern critics to privilege the high art of the tapestry (made primarily by men) over the low art of the spinning (women's work)

			Arachne; Ovid is sympathetic to her, Sandys's translation makes her into a political/sexual agitator; Browne pastoralizes her

	== The fate of spinning: Penelope and the Three Fates ==		== The fate of spinning: Penelope and the Three Fates ==