Adams and Barker 1993: Difference between revisions

From Whiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page with 'Adams, Thomas R. and Nicolas Barker. "A New Model for the Study of the Book." ''A Potencie of Life: Books in Society.'' Ed. Nicolas Barker. London: British Library, 1993. 5-43. …')
 
No edit summary
 
(4 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 13: Line 13:
:"The power of books is not just what strikes the eye, but what may be latent, to be disclosed in the future." (9)
:"The power of books is not just what strikes the eye, but what may be latent, to be disclosed in the future." (9)
* "latent power is vastly magnified by the multiplicity of copies" (9)
* "latent power is vastly magnified by the multiplicity of copies" (9)
bibliographers often too content "to dig their own small patch"; social historians can add much (10)
'''criticisms of Darnton's communication circuit''':
* term "publisher" is anachronistic
* shipper (simply providing a service as he would for any other commodity) not as important as more general lines of communication
* most importantly, ''deals with people rather than books'' (12); focuses on history of communication
* "it ignores the sheer randomness, the speculative uncertainty of the book trade." (12)
term "book" doesn't include broadsides, ephemera, etc.; Adams and Baker propose '''"bibliographical document"''' (13) -- limit is if "the agent's intention involves the process of duplication" (13)
'''new model''':
* still a circle of connected elements influenced by elements in the center
* but elements inverted
* indirect forces outside, exerting pressure
* five events in the life of a book: ''publishing, manufacturing, distribution, reception, survival''
'''publishing''':
* four parties: author, patron/financier, manufacturer, distributor
* four headings: creation, communication, profit, preservation
* "The decision to publish, not the creation of a text, is, then, the first step in the creation of a book." (18); often influenced heavily by factors not intrinsic to the text
'''manufacturing''':
* how to include the printing press in a more general history of technology? (18-9)
* manufacture of illustrations, graphics? (19)
* manufacture of paper, ink? (19)
* physical look and feel of the book carries evidence of provenance; "deserves more attention as an aspect of the impact of printing" (20)
* binding: structure and appearance (20); progressive decline in durability of both
* "Throughout the whole manufacturing process the historian must take into account the essential ingredient that made it all happen, labour, particularly the place and function of labour in a new technology." (21)
'''distribution''':
* begins the book's "dynamic phase" (22)
* four elements: initial impetus, consequent moving of books, destination (intentional, unintentional), momentum
* immediately after publishing, but also secondhand markets and how books survived to today
* various reasons to desire to own a book
'''reception''':
* initially "passive" and "mute" (27)
* evidence: direct documentation (published and private responses), popularity (reprintings, sales), influence, use (27)
* book authors and manufacturers can't control its use (29)
* literacy rates; what is reading? (30)
'''survival''':
* three stages:
** creation and initial reception (determined by physical form, size, subsequent popularity);
** comes to rest without any use (in danger of disappearing);
** book becomes desirable as an object (for text or in its own right)
"What we offer is a map." (39)

Latest revision as of 14:09, 29 August 2010

Adams, Thomas R. and Nicolas Barker. "A New Model for the Study of the Book." A Potencie of Life: Books in Society. Ed. Nicolas Barker. London: British Library, 1993. 5-43.

Martin, Febvre, The coming of the book -- began tradition of "the history of the book"

Eisenstein presented a critique of history with Printing Press -- social revolutions caused by printing press, rather than other way around; Darnton, too, focusing on Enlightenment

the bibliographer is thus "unexpectedly dragged into the limelight by academic historians" (6)

bibliography used to occupy same position as archaeology; but now seems doomed always to be a handmiden to other disciplines

quintessentially interdisciplinary

"The power of books is not just what strikes the eye, but what may be latent, to be disclosed in the future." (9)
  • "latent power is vastly magnified by the multiplicity of copies" (9)

bibliographers often too content "to dig their own small patch"; social historians can add much (10)

criticisms of Darnton's communication circuit:

  • term "publisher" is anachronistic
  • shipper (simply providing a service as he would for any other commodity) not as important as more general lines of communication
  • most importantly, deals with people rather than books (12); focuses on history of communication
  • "it ignores the sheer randomness, the speculative uncertainty of the book trade." (12)

term "book" doesn't include broadsides, ephemera, etc.; Adams and Baker propose "bibliographical document" (13) -- limit is if "the agent's intention involves the process of duplication" (13)

new model:

  • still a circle of connected elements influenced by elements in the center
  • but elements inverted
  • indirect forces outside, exerting pressure
  • five events in the life of a book: publishing, manufacturing, distribution, reception, survival

publishing:

  • four parties: author, patron/financier, manufacturer, distributor
  • four headings: creation, communication, profit, preservation
  • "The decision to publish, not the creation of a text, is, then, the first step in the creation of a book." (18); often influenced heavily by factors not intrinsic to the text

manufacturing:

  • how to include the printing press in a more general history of technology? (18-9)
  • manufacture of illustrations, graphics? (19)
  • manufacture of paper, ink? (19)
  • physical look and feel of the book carries evidence of provenance; "deserves more attention as an aspect of the impact of printing" (20)
  • binding: structure and appearance (20); progressive decline in durability of both
  • "Throughout the whole manufacturing process the historian must take into account the essential ingredient that made it all happen, labour, particularly the place and function of labour in a new technology." (21)

distribution:

  • begins the book's "dynamic phase" (22)
  • four elements: initial impetus, consequent moving of books, destination (intentional, unintentional), momentum
  • immediately after publishing, but also secondhand markets and how books survived to today
  • various reasons to desire to own a book

reception:

  • initially "passive" and "mute" (27)
  • evidence: direct documentation (published and private responses), popularity (reprintings, sales), influence, use (27)
  • book authors and manufacturers can't control its use (29)
  • literacy rates; what is reading? (30)

survival:

  • three stages:
    • creation and initial reception (determined by physical form, size, subsequent popularity);
    • comes to rest without any use (in danger of disappearing);
    • book becomes desirable as an object (for text or in its own right)

"What we offer is a map." (39)